As a managed service provider (MSP), you understand that your clients trust you with their most sensitive data and IT infrastructure. But what happens when that trust is compromised by a cyberattack? The stakes are higher than ever, and the financial, operational and reputational costs of a cyberattack can cripple your business.
The emotional toll of a cyberattack: A Wake-up call for MSPs
Imagine this: a cyberattack hits your MSP business, and within hours, your clients’ trust erodes. Systems are down, contracts are breached and your reputation is at stake. The financial losses are staggering, but the professional and personal toll can be just as devastating. For MSPs, the question isn’t if a cyberattack will happen—it’s when. And when it does, the right preparation can mean the difference between recovery and ruin.
While most MSPs are already aware of cybersecurity’s critical importance, many overlook one vital aspect: cyber insurance. It’s not just a financial safety net; it’s a cornerstone of a resilient business strategy.
In this blog, we’ll uncover the hidden costs of cyberattacks, explore why risk assessments are essential and highlight how cyber insurance is the ultimate safeguard for your MSP’s future.
Are you covered in the event of a data breach? Download your free cyber tookit
Why are MSPs prime targets for cyberattacks?
-
Supply chain attacks: A growing threat
MSPs are gateways to numerous client networks, making them irresistible targets for cybercriminals.
- Trend Insight: Supply chain attacks surged by 633% in 2022, with MSPs at the forefront of this alarming trend.
- Case Study: The Kaseya ransomware attack compromised thousands of businesses through a single MSP entry point, costing millions in damages.
These attacks don’t just exploit one vulnerability—they ripple across entire networks, making MSPs pivotal players in the broader cybersecurity landscape. As such, the stakes for MSPs are exponentially higher than for other businesses. The interconnected nature of MSPs’ operations amplifies the potential impact, making rigorous security measures and insurance safeguards essential.
-
Ransomware and financial exploitation
Ransomware remains one of the most pervasive threats for MSPs.
- The true costs: Beyond ransom payments, MSPs face operational downtime, legal fees and irreversible reputational damage.
- Fact check: Without cyber insurance, these costs can cripple an MSP’s financial stability, leaving recovery out of reach.
Ransomware attacks are evolving, cybercriminals now engage in “double extortion,” where they not only encrypt files but also threaten to leak sensitive client data unless an additional ransom is paid. This compounds the financial and reputational impact on MSPs, making preemptive protection critical.
Additionally, as ransomware-as-a-service (RaaS) platforms gain popularity, the barrier to entry for cybercriminals lowers, increasing the frequency of such attacks. This evolving threat landscape underscores the need for layered security and robust insurance coverage.
The hidden costs of cyberattacks for MSPs
A cyberattack impacts more than your bottom line, it disrupts every facet of your business. Here’s how:
-
Operational disruption
- Downtime from an attack halts service delivery, breaching SLAs and risking client contracts.
- Average downtime costs have soared to $9,000 per minute for MSPs, highlighting the financial strain of delayed recovery.
Even short disruptions can lead to cascading effects, such as missed deadlines, overburdened support teams and lost opportunities. For MSPs reliant on seamless operations, these delays can tarnish their reputation as reliable service providers. Furthermore, the added pressure on IT teams to restore systems quickly can result in burnout, compounding the operational strain and creating long-term workforce challenges.
-
Client trust and reputation
- Statistic: 60% of SMBs switch providers after a breach involving their MSP.
- The loss of trust can lead to long-term attrition and damaged relationships, reducing lifetime customer value.
Rebuilding trust isn’t just about damage control; it requires transparency, investment in upgraded security measures and consistent communication. Unfortunately, these efforts often take months or years to yield results, further eroding profitability. Beyond financial costs, losing key clients to competitors can impact an MSP’s market position and growth trajectory, making preventative measures an invaluable investment.
-
Legal and regulatory fallout
- Breaches often result in hefty fines or lawsuits under GDPR, HIPAA, or CCPA.
- Cyber insurance can mitigate these costs by covering breach notification expenses and reducing penalties.
In addition to fines, MSPs may face audits or investigations that consume time and resources, diverting focus from core business operations. Staying compliant isn’t optional, it’s a critical component of risk management. With regulations continually evolving, MSPs must remain vigilant, updating their security protocols and insurance coverage to align with current legal standards.
The role of risk assessments in cyber insurance
Why risk assessments matter
Risk assessments are not just a compliance checkbox—they’re a critical tool for identifying vulnerabilities and securing the right cyber insurance coverage.
- Insurance requirements: Providers often mandate risk assessments to determine coverage eligibility and premiums.
- Proactive insights: By identifying weaknesses, MSPs can strengthen their security posture before attackers exploit them.
Performing regular assessments also builds confidence with clients, demonstrating your commitment to protecting their data and infrastructure. This proactive approach can be a differentiator in a competitive market. Additionally, comprehensive assessments enable MSPs to prioritize investments in security tools and training, ensuring resources are allocated where they’ll have the greatest impact.
How to perform a risk assessment
- Evaluate assets: Identify critical client networks, sensitive data, and infrastructure.
- Conduct vulnerability scans: Use advanced tools to pinpoint risks.
- Simulate attacks: Perform penetration testing to uncover exploitable weaknesses.
Adding to this, MSPs should involve third-party auditors to validate their findings and recommend actionable improvements. Independent evaluations often uncover blind spots that internal teams might overlook. Regular follow-ups on these assessments can track progress and ensure sustained improvement over time.
Common MSP vulnerabilities
- Unpatched software and outdated systems.
- Misconfigured remote access tools.
- Inadequate employee training on phishing and social engineering.
Addressing these vulnerabilities not only reduces risk but also enhances eligibility for lower cyber insurance premiums, providing a dual benefit. Proactive remediation efforts also position MSPs as trusted advisors to their clients, fostering deeper partnerships and improved client retention.
Trends in cyber insurance for MSPs
AI-driven threats: The new frontier
As AI technology evolves, so do cyber threats. Attackers are leveraging AI to execute more sophisticated and targeted attacks.
- Emerging risks: AI-powered phishing, deepfake scams and automated malware are on the rise.
- Insurance adaptations: Cyber insurance providers are now offering coverage tailored to AI-specific threats, ensuring MSPs stay protected against these emerging dangers.
For example, AI-driven reconnaissance tools allow cybercriminals to identify and exploit vulnerabilities faster than ever. MSPs must adopt equally advanced defenses to stay ahead of these innovations. Moreover, as AI continues to transform the threat landscape, insurers are refining their policies to include predictive analytics, offering tailored recommendations to policyholders.
Dynamic insurance models
Traditional policies are being replaced by dynamic, usage-based models that adapt in real-time to an MSP’s security posture.
- Benefit: MSPs with robust risk management practices can lower their premiums by demonstrating a proactive approach to cybersecurity.
This shift also incentivizes ongoing security investments, encouraging MSPs to adopt cutting-edge tools and practices that reduce overall exposure. These dynamic models create a mutually beneficial relationship between insurers and MSPs, aligning both parties’ interests in minimizing risk.
Proactive vs. reactive security: Why both matter
Many MSPs view cyber insurance as a reactive measure, but it’s most effective when paired with proactive security strategies.
Proactive security measures
- Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR): Stops threats before they escalate.
- Network monitoring: Provides real-time visibility into traffic patterns.
- Employee training: Empowers teams to recognize phishing and social engineering tactics.
Proactivity also fosters a security-first culture within your organization, ensuring employees at all levels prioritize risk mitigation in their daily activities. Regularly updated training programs can help employees stay ahead of evolving threats, reinforcing their role as the first line of defense.
How cyber insurance complements proactivity
- Covers residual risks that even the best defenses can’t eliminate.
- Reduces the financial impact of breaches, ensuring business continuity.
Moreover, the synergy between proactive measures and cyber insurance creates a layered defense system, significantly improving resilience against attacks. This combination ensures that MSPs can recover not just financially but also operationally, minimizing long-term damage. By integrating these strategies, MSPs can build a comprehensive risk management framework that aligns with their growth objectives.
Quick reference checklist for MSPs
Use this checklist to evaluate your readiness for cyber insurance:
- Do you have a cybersecurity framework in place (e.g., NIST, CIS)?
- Have you conducted a recent risk assessment? (Try ours for free here)
- Are you using proactive tools like EDR and SIEM?
- Do you understand the factors that affect cyber insurance premiums?
- Have you reviewed your compliance obligations?
Are you ready to take the next step in protecting your MSP?
Cyber insurance isn’t just a safety net to minimize cyberattack costs for MSPs; it’s a business enabler that ensures your MSP can recover quickly and confidently after a cyberattack. But the journey starts with understanding your risks.
At Sherweb, we provide the tools and expertise MSPs need to navigate the complex world of cybersecurity and cyber insurance. Our Cyber Insurance Toolkit is designed to help you assess your vulnerabilities, strengthen your security posture, and secure the right coverage for your business.
Take the first step today: Partner with a trusted industry leader and safeguard your future. Explore our free resources and ensure your MSP is ready for whatever comes next.
